Titanic, the rarely performed musical theater gem, known for its captivating story and memorable music, will be brought to life by Starring Buffalo at Shea’s 710 theatre, May 31 and June 1.

And, like the Hope, the gem at the center of Titanic boasts a long history of owners including King Louis XIV of France. But the 56-carat Coeur de la Mer (Heart of the Ocean)—the pendant that ...